TierFolk

Candy Tier List

October is when candy rankings get serious, because the order decides who trades what after trick-or-treating. This board holds 84 chocolate bars, gummies, lollipops and sour candies, and a Halloween preset trims it to the 33 treats that usually end up in the bucket.

See our ranking and why

  • Halloween preset with 33 staples
  • US, Canada and UK candy aisles
  • Tier-by-tier video reveal
Fast on a phone. Tap an item, then a tier, or rank one by one with big buttons.
Your pictures stay here. They are resized and kept in your browser, never uploaded.
Clean exports. HD PNG in social sizes and a video reveal, with no watermark.
Rank with friends. Merge everyone's links into one group tier list.

Updated

How to rank the candy template

  1. Pick the Halloween presetChoose Halloween candy to load the 33 bucket regulars, or keep all 84 for a full candy aisle ranking with British and Canadian bars.
  2. Rank it yourself or start from oursBegin with empty tiers, or load our ranking below and move whatever offends you. Tap a candy, then tap the tier it deserves.
  3. Save S tier for the revealRecord the video reveal for TikTok or Shorts so the top row lands last, or download a clean PNG for the family group chat.

Our ranking

One opinion from the TierFolk editors, argued tier by tier below. Updated 2026-11-13. How we rank.

S
  • Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
  • Snickers
  • Kit Kat
  • Twix
  • Kinder Bueno
  • Maltesers
A
  • M&M's
  • Ferrero Rocher
  • Cadbury Dairy Milk
  • Crunchie
  • Butterfinger
  • Heath
  • Coffee Crisp
  • Caramilk
  • Wispa
  • Skittles
  • Starburst
  • Sour Patch Kids
  • Hi-Chew
  • Cadbury Creme Egg
B
  • Hershey's Milk Chocolate
  • Hershey's Kisses
  • Milky Way
  • 3 Musketeers
  • Almond Joy
  • York Peppermint Pattie
  • Rolo
  • Toblerone
  • Galaxy
  • Aero
  • Smarties (UK and Canada)
  • Haribo Goldbears
  • Swedish Fish
  • Nerds
  • Jolly Rancher
  • Wine Gums
  • Fuzzy Peaches
C
  • 100 Grand
  • Crunch
  • Whoppers
  • Milk Duds
  • PayDay
  • Twizzlers
  • Airheads
  • Laffy Taffy
  • Mike and Ike
  • Tootsie Pops
  • Dum Dums
  • Warheads
  • Smarties (US)
  • Ring Pop
  • Pop Rocks
  • Lemonheads
D
  • Candy Corn
  • Tootsie Roll
  • Good & Plenty
  • Peeps
  • Mounds
  • Raisinets

S tier. Every one of these mixes at least two textures, and that is why people reach for them first. Reese's balances salty peanut butter with milk chocolate, Snickers stacks nougat, caramel and peanuts, and Kit Kat and Twix bring the snap of a wafer or cookie. Kinder Bueno and Maltesers win on lightness: you can finish one and still want another.

A tier. Strong favorites with one small limit each. M&M's and Dairy Milk are great but simple, Ferrero Rocher feels like a gift more than a snack, and Butterfinger, Heath, Crunchie and Coffee Crisp hinge on whether you love their crunchy centers. Skittles, Starburst, Sour Patch Kids and Hi-Chew lead the chewy side. The Creme Egg would rise if it were sold all year.

B tier. Good candy that rarely starts a fight. The Hershey bar and Kisses are classic but plain next to filled bars, Milky Way and 3 Musketeers are soft and sweet without much contrast, and Almond Joy and York divide the room on coconut and mint. Goldbears, Swedish Fish, Wine Gums and Fuzzy Peaches are dependable chews, and Nerds and Jolly Rancher deliver bright fruit flavor.

C tier. Fun more than delicious. Whoppers and Milk Duds are moviegoer picks that can stick to your teeth, Crunch and 100 Grand are pleasant but easy to forget, and PayDay suits people who like salty over sweet. The lollipops, Warheads, Pop Rocks and Ring Pop are about the experience, the pucker or the novelty, which is great at a party and less great as a favorite.

D tier. Each has a loyal crowd, and for them this row is a crime. For most tasters, though, these need a specific mood. Candy Corn and Peeps are mostly about the season, Tootsie Roll is a mild chocolate chew, and Good & Plenty asks you to love licorice. Mounds is Almond Joy minus the almond and the milk chocolate, and Raisinets ask you to welcome fruit inside your chocolate.

All 84 items in this template
  • Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
  • Snickers
  • M&M's
  • Kit Kat
  • Twix
  • Hershey's Milk Chocolate
  • Hershey's Kisses
  • Milky Way
  • 3 Musketeers
  • Butterfinger
  • Baby Ruth
  • Almond Joy
  • Mounds
  • Whoppers
  • Milk Duds
  • Heath
  • York Peppermint Pattie
  • Rolo
  • PayDay
  • 100 Grand
  • Crunch
  • Raisinets
  • Junior Mints
  • Kinder Bueno
  • Ferrero Rocher
  • Toblerone
  • Skittles
  • Starburst
  • Sour Patch Kids
  • Swedish Fish
  • Haribo Goldbears
  • Twizzlers
  • Red Vines
  • Mike and Ike
  • Hot Tamales
  • Laffy Taffy
  • Airheads
  • Tootsie Roll
  • Hi-Chew
  • Jelly Belly
  • Trolli Sour Brite Crawlers
  • Peeps
  • Candy Corn
  • Charleston Chew
  • Good & Plenty
  • Jolly Rancher
  • Nerds
  • Smarties (US)
  • Dum Dums
  • Tootsie Pops
  • Lemonheads
  • Warheads
  • Life Savers
  • Werther's Original
  • Pop Rocks
  • Ring Pop
  • SweeTARTS
  • Cadbury Dairy Milk
  • Cadbury Creme Egg
  • Maltesers
  • Aero
  • Crunchie
  • Galaxy
  • Wispa
  • Twirl
  • Flake
  • Double Decker
  • Mars
  • Bounty
  • Toffee Crisp
  • Smarties (UK and Canada)
  • Coffee Crisp
  • Caramilk
  • Mr. Big
  • Oh Henry!
  • Crispy Crunch
  • Wunderbar
  • Fruit Pastilles
  • Wine Gums
  • Jelly Babies
  • Haribo Starmix
  • Fuzzy Peaches
  • Rockets
  • Love Hearts

Disagree? Press Start from our ranking above and move things, or Rank it yourself from an empty board.

Halloween candy tier list: the 33-candy preset

Thirty-three candies make the Halloween cut: the fun-size bars (Snickers, Twix, Kit Kat, Milky Way, 3 Musketeers, Butterfinger), the bags of Skittles, Starburst and Sour Patch Kids, the lollipops like Dum Dums and Tootsie Pops, the sour dare that is Warheads, and of course Candy Corn. It is the set you would expect to pour out of a pillowcase on the living room floor.

Want the bucket in the picture? Add photos of your own candy from your device. They are resized and kept in this browser, never uploaded, so a quick snapshot of the pile can sit right next to the name tiles.

Movie boxes, imports and holiday-only candy

Beyond the Halloween regulars, the full board adds movie-theater boxes (Junior Mints, Raisinets, Hot Tamales), road-trip picks like Hi-Chew and Jelly Belly, and holiday-only candy such as Peeps and the Cadbury Creme Egg. Kinder Bueno, Ferrero Rocher and Toblerone round out the chocolate side.

Britain and Canada each bring a shelf of their own. UK fans get Cadbury Dairy Milk, Galaxy, Wispa, Twirl, Flake, Double Decker, Toffee Crisp, Jelly Babies and Love Hearts. Canadians get Coffee Crisp, Caramilk, Mr. Big, Oh Henry!, Crispy Crunch, Wunderbar, Fuzzy Peaches and Rockets. Every candy is a name on a pastel tile colored by type, with no wrappers or logos.

US, UK and Canadian aisles, and the two Smarties

Country presets keep the board fair for people who shop in the same aisles: 58 candies for the US, 38 for Canada and 31 for the UK. Use them when a chocolate bar tier list for the UK or Canada is the actual question, since a Londoner should not have to rank PayDay and a Texan has probably never met a Wunderbar.

Type presets split the argument by texture. Chocolate holds 46 bars and bites, gummy and chewy has 24, and hard and sour has 14. A chocolate-only ranking is calmer; the gummy round is where friendships wobble, because licorice fans and licorice skeptics rarely meet in the middle.

Two names clash, so both are spelled out. Smarties (US) are tangy pressed tablets sold in rolls, while Smarties (UK and Canada) are sugar-coated chocolate buttons. Canada's Rockets are the same style of chalky tablet that Americans call Smarties. The British Milky Way is a different bar from the American one, so only the US version is here. Once the candy is settled, the ice cream flavors tier list keeps the dessert argument going.

Texture, ratio and the jacket-pocket test

Taste comes first, but texture decides most close calls: snap versus chew, crunch versus melt, how a bar holds up after an hour in a jacket pocket. Ratio matters too. Plenty of debates are really about how much peanut butter, caramel or wafer sits under the chocolate.

A sticky lollipop that glues itself to everything else in the bag loses a few points, and so does a bar that turns to soup in a warm car. Some households rank by "would you hand this out at your own door", which is a kinder list and a different one.

Where the candy names come from

Reese's Peanut Butter Cups were created by H.B. Reese in Hershey, Pennsylvania, in 1928, after he left a job at the Hershey dairy farms to make candy. Candy corn goes back to the late 1800s, which makes it one of the oldest candies on the board and a fitting villain for so many worst-candy lists.

3 Musketeers got its name because the bar once came as three pieces in three flavors: chocolate, vanilla and strawberry. Snickers is often said to be named after a horse owned by the Mars family. And the Baby Ruth name has been argued about for a century; the maker said it honored President Grover Cleveland's daughter Ruth, though many people assume it was the ballplayer.

Trading values after trick-or-treating

On November 1 a tier list turns into an exchange rate. A full-size Reese's buys two or three fun-size bars from a younger sibling, a box of Nerds trades about even with Skittles, and Candy Corn is worth whatever someone will take it for. Ranking for trade value is not the same as ranking for taste: a candy everyone wants climbs, even if it is not your own favorite.

Try two boards this season. Fill the first one before the night, from memory, then rank the real haul on the table and compare. Your D row becomes the trading pile. Streamers can reveal the list tier by tier and let chat guess each row before it lands, which works best when the S row is saved for last.

For a Halloween party, send the preset as one link before the night, ask every guest to reply with their ranked link, and paste the replies into the group tier list to see the house verdict and the most disputed candies. If two bars keep tying, settle them pair by pair with the candy bracket tool, then carry on to the cereal tier list, where the fall monster cereals wait.

Questions

What is the best Halloween candy?

Chocolate with a filling usually wins. Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Snickers, Twix and Kit Kat sit near the top of most rankings, ours included, because they taste good, keep well in a bag and trade easily. Sour fans will argue for Sour Patch Kids, and that is a fair fight. Load the Halloween preset and put your own order to the test.

What is the worst Halloween candy?

Candy Corn is the classic answer and often shows up at the bottom of online polls, though it has a devoted fan base that buys it every fall. Tootsie Roll, Good & Plenty and plain lollipops also get low marks from many people. Our ranking puts them low but not in an F row: worst depends a lot on who is eating.

How do I make a Halloween candy tier list?

Choose the Halloween candy preset, which loads 33 candies people commonly hand out. Pick Rank it yourself, then tap each candy and a tier, or tap One by one for a single big card at a time. Rename rows if you like, for example "Trade bait" or "Keep forever", and export a PNG or record the video reveal.

Can I make a chocolate bar tier list for the UK or Canada?

Yes. The UK preset holds 31 candies, including Cadbury Dairy Milk, Galaxy, Wispa, Twirl, Double Decker and Maltesers. The Canada preset holds 38, with Coffee Crisp, Caramilk, Mr. Big and Crispy Crunch. To rank only chocolate, start from either preset and leave the gummies and hard candies in the pool, or use the Chocolate preset for every bar at once.

Are Smarties the same in the US and the UK?

No, they are two different candies with the same name. American Smarties are small, tangy tablets wrapped in rolls, a Halloween bucket regular. Smarties in the UK and Canada are colorful sugar-coated chocolate buttons. The board lists them as Smarties (US) and Smarties (UK and Canada), so both can be ranked side by side without confusion.

Can I add a candy that is not in the template?

Type the name into the item box, paste several names at once, or add a picture from your device, and the new candy joins the pool. That covers local favorites and limited flavors. Additions live in your copy only and save to My lists on this device. To share them with friends, send a link or a backup file.