TierFolk

Ice Cream Flavors Tier List

Every freezer case has its loyal regulars and its mystery tubs. This board holds 45 flavors, from plain vanilla to pistachio, blue moon and ube, each drawn as a tinted scoop. Sort them by what you would actually order at the counter, and share the board while the argument is still fresh.

See our ranking and why

  • 45 flavors as drawn scoops
  • Our ranking, argued tier by tier
  • Video reveal for Shorts and Reels
Fast on a phone. Tap an item, then a tier, or rank one by one with big buttons.
Your pictures stay here. They are resized and kept in your browser, never uploaded.
Clean exports. HD PNG in social sizes and a video reveal, with no watermark.
Rank with friends. Merge everyone's links into one group tier list.

Updated

How to rank the ice cream flavors template

  1. Pick a flavor familyTap a preset chip such as Classics, Chocolate lovers or Fruity to shrink the pool, or keep all 45 scoops on the board.
  2. Scoop them into tiersSelect a flavor and then its row, drag it across, or tap One by one so each scoop gets judged on its own.
  3. Serve the resultSave an unbranded PNG, record the reveal clip, or pass the template link around so everyone judges the same tubs.

Our ranking

One opinion from the TierFolk editors, argued tier by tier below. Updated 2026-11-13. How we rank.

S
  • Mint chocolate chip
  • Cookies and cream
  • Salted caramel
  • Chocolate chip cookie dough
  • Pistachio
A
  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Coffee
  • Peanut butter cup
  • Moose tracks
  • Rocky road
  • Black raspberry
  • Butter pecan
  • Dulce de leche
  • French vanilla
B
  • Strawberry
  • Cookie dough
  • Chocolate chip
  • Chocolate peanut butter
  • Brownie batter
  • Mango
  • Coconut
  • Green tea
  • Black sesame
  • Ube
  • Maple walnut
  • Cheesecake
  • Raspberry
C
  • Neapolitan
  • Rainbow sherbet
  • Lemon
  • Peach
  • Black cherry
  • Banana
  • Pumpkin
  • Peppermint
  • Cinnamon
  • Spumoni
  • Butterscotch
D
  • Birthday cake
  • Cotton candy
  • Eggnog
  • Rum raisin
  • Blue moon
F
  • Bubble gum

S tier. Each of these has contrast built in. Mint chocolate chip pairs a cool base with dark chips, cookies and cream gives crunch in every bite, and salted caramel balances sugar with salt. Chocolate chip cookie dough packs two mix-ins into one scoop. Pistachio is the outlier: no chunks, but a nutty, savory depth that nothing else on the board has.

A tier. These are the scoops you never regret. Vanilla and chocolate earn their place by working on their own, in a sundae and next to pie. Coffee and dulce de leche taste grown-up without being odd. Peanut butter cup, moose tracks and rocky road deliver real mix-ins, while black raspberry and butter pecan are regional favorites that hold up anywhere.

B tier. Good scoops with one catch each. Strawberry often tastes more of sugar than berry, and plain cookie dough loses to the version with chocolate chips. Brownie batter and chocolate peanut butter get heavy after a few spoonfuls. Mango, green tea, black sesame and ube are excellent when a shop makes them well, which is not every shop.

C tier. Fine in the right moment, rarely the first pick. Neapolitan is three flavors where the strawberry stripe usually disappears last. Lemon, peach and rainbow sherbet are refreshing but light. Pumpkin and peppermint belong to their season, cinnamon works best next to warm pie, and spumoni and butterscotch feel like a flavor from a grandparent's freezer.

D tier. Sweetness or novelty ahead of flavor. Birthday cake and cotton candy taste mostly of sugar and food coloring, and the sprinkles rarely help. Eggnog is a once-a-year treat at most. Rum raisin hides chewy raisins that many eaters pick out, and blue moon is famous because nobody can say what it tastes like, which makes it fun to try once.

F tier. The only scoop with a built-in problem: the gum pieces freeze rock hard, then sit in your mouth after the ice cream is gone, so you either chew while eating or spit them out. The flavor itself is pleasant, but a scoop should not leave you hunting for a napkin.

All 45 items in this template
  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Strawberry
  • Mint chocolate chip
  • Cookies and cream
  • Cookie dough
  • Rocky road
  • Butter pecan
  • Pistachio
  • Neapolitan
  • Coffee
  • Chocolate chip
  • Salted caramel
  • Moose tracks
  • Birthday cake
  • Rainbow sherbet
  • Mango
  • Coconut
  • Green tea
  • Cotton candy
  • Bubble gum
  • Blue moon
  • Spumoni
  • Lemon
  • Raspberry
  • Black raspberry
  • Banana
  • Peach
  • Black cherry
  • Rum raisin
  • Cinnamon
  • Dulce de leche
  • Cheesecake
  • Brownie batter
  • Chocolate peanut butter
  • Peanut butter cup
  • Butterscotch
  • French vanilla
  • Black sesame
  • Ube
  • Pumpkin
  • Eggnog
  • Peppermint
  • Maple walnut
  • Chocolate chip cookie dough

Disagree? Press Start from our ranking above and move things, or Rank it yourself from an empty board.

From vanilla to ube: the 45 scoops

The set starts with the flavors every scoop shop carries: vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cookies and cream, mint chocolate chip and coffee. From there it branches into mix-in heavyweights such as rocky road, moose tracks and brownie batter, fruit scoops from mango to black cherry, nut flavors like butter pecan and maple walnut, and the sugary end of the counter, where cotton candy, bubble gum and birthday cake live.

A handful of flavors sit outside every family on purpose: green tea, black sesame, ube, spumoni, rum raisin and cinnamon. They are the tiles most likely to split a group, because half the room has never tasted them and the other half has strong feelings. Every name here is a generic flavor, not a brand, so a pint from your favorite creamery can be typed in as an extra tile.

Six flavor families, and the scoops in two

Classics holds 11 scoops, the safe opener for any group. Chocolate lovers gathers 9, from plain chocolate to chocolate peanut butter. Fruity has 10, nutty has 6, and Extra sweet collects 8 of the candy-colored, caramel-heavy picks. Seasonal is the smallest at 3: pumpkin, eggnog and peppermint, the flavors that show up in fall and winter and vanish again.

Some scoops belong to two families. Rocky road counts as chocolate and nutty, and chocolate chip cookie dough sits in both Classics and Chocolate lovers. That overlap is handy: run the Chocolate lovers round first, then the Nutty round, and see whether rocky road keeps the same tier when the competition changes.

Base, mix-ins and near-twins

Flavor is only part of it. Texture matters just as much: a smooth custard base, chunks you can find in every spoonful, or a ribbon of fudge that runs out halfway down the pint. Mix-ins are a fair thing to judge, and so is how a flavor behaves in a cone on a hot afternoon, since fruit sorbet-style scoops and sherbet melt differently from a dense chocolate.

Decide early how to treat near-twins. Vanilla and French vanilla, cookie dough and chocolate chip cookie dough, raspberry and black raspberry are separate tiles here, and some groups like to line them up next to each other to settle which version wins. Others drop one of each pair to keep the board tidy. Either way, put the rule in the title so nobody accuses you of splitting votes. Fruit-flavored scoops start a second debate on the real fruit tier list.

Regional scoops and flavors from around the world

Blue moon is the best-known regional oddity: a bright blue scoop found mostly in the Upper Midwest, with a taste people still argue about trying to describe. Black raspberry is a summer staple in parts of the Northeast and Ohio, and maple walnut is an old favorite in New England and Canada. If a flavor is unheard of where you live, give it a row labeled Haven't had it rather than guessing.

Several tiles travel further. Ube, the purple yam, comes from Filipino desserts. Green tea and black sesame are standard in Japanese and other East Asian shops. Dulce de leche, a slow-cooked milk caramel, is loved across Latin America, and spumoni, layered with fruit and nuts, is an Italian-American classic. Neapolitan is named after Naples and stacks vanilla, chocolate and strawberry in one brick.

Cup, cone or sundae: the same scoop three ways

A flavor can change tiers depending on how it is served. In a cup, the base does all the work, so pistachio, coffee and plain vanilla shine. In a cone, melt speed and drips decide the day: dense chocolate and cookies and cream hold their shape, while sherbet and fruit scoops run fast on a hot afternoon. In a sundae, vanilla jumps up the board, because hot fudge and caramel need a quiet partner.

Try ranking the same set twice with the tiers renamed, once as "Best in a cone" and once as "Best under hot fudge". The scoops that hold the same row both times are the real all-rounders. On stream, the video reveal suits a flavor list well: save mint chocolate chip for last and let the chat fight about toothpaste.

When ties feel like cheating, a flavor bracket forces one winner, and the rest of dessert night waits among the other food templates. A sweeter cousin of this board is the candy tier list.

National Ice Cream Month and other scoop facts

July is National Ice Cream Month in the United States, set by a presidential proclamation in 1984. French vanilla usually means a custard base made with egg yolks, which is why it looks more yellow than plain vanilla. And the bright green of many mint chip scoops comes from added coloring; mint ice cream without it is pale white.

Questions

What is the best ice cream flavor?

There is no single winner, and that is the fun of ranking them. Polls of American eaters keep placing vanilla and chocolate at or near the top, partly because they go with everything. Our own S tier leans toward flavors with mix-ins and contrast, such as mint chocolate chip and salted caramel. Rank yours and compare it with ours using the button above the board.

What are the most common ice cream flavors?

The Classics preset gathers them: vanilla, French vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, Neapolitan, mint chocolate chip, cookies and cream, cookie dough, chocolate chip cookie dough, chocolate chip and coffee. Nearly every scoop shop and grocery freezer carries most of these. The full set adds 34 more, from butter pecan and rocky road to regional and seasonal scoops.

How do I make an ice cream tier list?

Open this page and the 45 flavors are already in the pool. Tap a preset chip for a quicker round, then place each scoop in a tier by tapping, dragging or using One by one. Relabel the rows if letters feel too formal, say Order again down to Never again, then download the picture or copy the link.

What is the difference between ice cream, gelato and sherbet?

In the US, a product sold as ice cream must contain at least 10 percent milkfat. Gelato usually has more milk and less cream, is churned more slowly so it holds less air, and is served a little warmer, which makes it dense and intense. Sherbet is mostly fruit and sugar with a small amount of dairy, and sorbet has none. All of them can share one board.

Can I rank an ice cream truck menu?

Sure. Truck menus are mostly novelties, such as bars, cones and frozen treats on a stick, so they work best as a fresh list. Type or paste the items one per line, or snap photos of the menu board and add them as pictures. The same tiers, exports and share options apply.

What flavor is blue moon ice cream?

Nobody quite agrees, which is part of its charm. People compare it to marshmallow, almond extract, raspberry or the milk left after a bowl of fruity cereal, and recipes vary from one dairy to the next. It is a regional scoop found mostly in the Upper Midwest, and its exact origin is disputed. Try it once before you place it, or give it a "Haven't had it" row.

Pictures: Scoop drawings: TierFolk. Flavors are generic, not brands. Full picture credits.