TierFolk

Thanksgiving Food Tier List

Every family has one dish that would cause a scene if it went missing, and one that nobody touches. This board sets out 26 of them, from the roast turkey to deviled eggs and butternut squash soup. Rank the table before dinner, then defend your stuffing placement over pie.

See our ranking and why

  • 26 dishes in our own drawings
  • Merge the whole family's picks
  • Tier-by-tier video reveal
Fast on a phone. Tap an item, then a tier, or rank one by one with big buttons.
Your pictures stay here. They are resized and kept in your browser, never uploaded.
Clean exports. HD PNG in social sizes and a video reveal, with no watermark.
Rank with friends. Merge everyone's links into one group tier list.

Updated

How to rank the thanksgiving food template

  1. Set the tableBegin with The classic table preset for twelve core dishes, or open all 26 to bring in ham, collard greens and cornbread.
  2. Pass the platesPut each dish in a row with a tap or a drag. The One by one card is handy on a phone between helpings.
  3. Compare relativesText the template link to cousins, gather the ranked links they reply with, and combine them into one family verdict.

Our ranking

One opinion from the TierFolk editors, argued tier by tier below. Updated 2026-11-13. How we rank.

S
  • Stuffing
  • Mashed potatoes
  • Gravy
  • Mac and cheese
A
  • Roast turkey
  • Pecan pie
  • Pumpkin pie
  • Sweet potato casserole
  • Dinner rolls
  • Cornbread
  • Apple pie
B
  • Cranberry sauce
  • Green bean casserole
  • Collard greens
  • Sweet potato pie
  • Deviled eggs
  • Glazed ham
  • Biscuits
  • Crescent rolls
C
  • Candied yams
  • Corn on the cob
  • Roasted vegetables
  • Brussels sprouts
  • Butternut squash soup
D
  • Green salad
  • Cheese and crackers

S tier. These are the dishes people pile highest and miss most when they are gone. Stuffing is one of the few dishes most people never make the rest of the year. Mashed potatoes and gravy are a single unit, and gravy fixes a dry turkey. Mac and cheese, baked with a crust, is comfort food that wins over every age at the table.

A tier. The pillars of the meal, each a step short of perfect. Turkey is the reason for the feast but dries out easily and leans on gravy. Pumpkin and pecan pie are the defining desserts, and apple pie is the safe crowd pleaser. Sweet potato casserole is dessert on the dinner plate, and warm rolls or cornbread mop up everything else.

B tier. Strong supporting cast. Cranberry sauce cuts through the richness and makes leftover sandwiches work. Green bean casserole and collard greens bring the only green on many plates. Sweet potato pie rivals pumpkin in the South. Deviled eggs vanish before dinner, ham is a fine second main, and biscuits and crescent rolls are good but rarely remembered.

C tier. Fine dishes that get lost on a crowded table. Candied yams overlap with sweet potato casserole and usually lose that contest. Corn on the cob tastes like July, a summer side that some tables keep for nostalgia. Roasted vegetables and Brussels sprouts are healthy and pleasant but rarely anyone's highlight, and soup fills the stomach before the main event.

D tier. Neither is bad, but neither is why anyone comes to Thanksgiving. A green salad is the plate's polite gesture, often untouched and soggy by the time someone remembers it. Cheese and crackers are an everyday snack that spoils appetites an hour before the real food, which on this day of all days is a strategic mistake.

All 26 items in this template
  • Roast turkey
  • Mashed potatoes
  • Gravy
  • Stuffing
  • Cranberry sauce
  • Green bean casserole
  • Sweet potato casserole
  • Mac and cheese
  • Dinner rolls
  • Cornbread
  • Corn on the cob
  • Pumpkin pie
  • Apple pie
  • Pecan pie
  • Sweet potato pie
  • Glazed ham
  • Deviled eggs
  • Brussels sprouts
  • Green salad
  • Crescent rolls
  • Candied yams
  • Collard greens
  • Butternut squash soup
  • Roasted vegetables
  • Biscuits
  • Cheese and crackers

Disagree? Press Start from our ranking above and move things, or Rank it yourself from an empty board.

The classic table: twelve dishes

The classic table preset is the menu most Americans picture: roast turkey, mashed potatoes, gravy, stuffing, cranberry sauce, green bean casserole, sweet potato casserole, mac and cheese, dinner rolls and corn on the cob, with pumpkin pie and apple pie waiting on the counter. Twelve dishes is a short, sharp round that a whole table can finish before the turkey is carved.

Everything else on the board fills out the spread. Glazed ham is the second main for families who find turkey dry. Deviled eggs and cheese and crackers hold everyone over while the oven is busy. Sides run from Brussels sprouts and roasted vegetables to candied yams and butternut squash soup.

Sides only, four pies and the bread basket

Many people say the sides are the real meal, and the Sides only preset puts that to the test with 14 dishes and no turkey to hide behind. Desserts is a four-pie showdown between pumpkin, apple, pecan and sweet potato. Breads and rolls pits dinner rolls against cornbread, crescent rolls and biscuits, a smaller fight with surprisingly loud fans.

Running the presets one after another works well for a big family. Do sides while the bird rests, desserts after the plates are cleared, and save the full board for the drive home.

Dressing, sauerkraut and oyster stuffing: regional tables

Thanksgiving tables vary by region and by family. Across the South, cornbread dressing often replaces bread stuffing, collard greens and mac and cheese count as essentials, and sweet potato pie competes with pumpkin. In many Southern and Black American households, baked mac and cheese is one of the dishes the table is built around. Some coastal families make oyster stuffing, and Baltimore is known for setting sauerkraut next to the turkey.

Even the names start arguments. Stuffing cooked inside the bird and dressing baked in a pan are often the same recipe with a different home, and which word a family uses tends to follow where it grew up. Candied yams are usually sweet potatoes, since true yams are rare in US grocery stores. If your table has a dish this set lacks, type it in: tamales, pierogi, lumpia and lasagna all turn up on plenty of Thanksgiving tables.

Plate value, leftover value and gravy

Judge each dish on the plate and on Friday. Leftover value is a real criterion, since turkey, stuffing and cranberry sauce rebuild into the best sandwich of the year, while a green salad does not survive the night. Gravy deserves credit for improving everything it touches, even if it is not a dish on its own.

Rank your family's version, not an ideal one. A dry turkey is a dry turkey, and an aunt's famous casserole can outrank any recipe from a magazine. If someone insists on judging the canned cranberry sauce, with the ridges from the can still on it, against the homemade kind, add both and let the table decide.

Plan the menu before the fourth Thursday

US Thanksgiving falls on the fourth Thursday of November, and Canada celebrates on the second Monday of October, so a ranking can start weeks ahead. Rank the week before to plan the menu: dishes that land in D two years running can quietly leave the shopping list. Friendsgiving hosts can send the board in advance and build the menu around the S row.

On the day itself, have everyone rank on their phones and merge the links with the family group tier list to settle the dessert debate with numbers. To force a single winning pie, run the four desserts through a pie bracket.

Plymouth 1621, Lincoln 1863, casserole 1955

The holiday traces back to a 1621 harvest celebration in Plymouth shared by English colonists and Wampanoag people; accounts mention wild fowl and deer, not pumpkin pie. Abraham Lincoln proclaimed a national Thanksgiving in 1863, after years of letters from the magazine editor Sarah Josepha Hale. Green bean casserole is much newer: it was created in a Campbell Soup Company test kitchen in 1955.

Once the dinner is ranked, the rest of the holiday season is waiting in the other food tier lists, and the vegetables tier list gives the Brussels sprouts a second chance.

Questions

What is the best Thanksgiving side dish?

Mashed potatoes and stuffing are the usual front runners, since they pair with gravy and fill the plate. Baked mac and cheese is a centerpiece in many Southern and Black American households, and some people swear by sweet potato casserole. Our ranking puts stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy and mac and cheese in S. Try the Sides only preset to find your own answer.

What foods are on a traditional Thanksgiving menu?

The core is roast turkey with stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy and cranberry sauce, plus a green vegetable such as green bean casserole, a sweet potato dish, rolls and pumpkin pie. Regional tables add cornbread dressing, collard greens, mac and cheese or sweet potato pie. The classic table preset collects twelve of the dishes most families serve.

How do I make a Thanksgiving food tier list?

All 26 dishes load with the page, sitting below the empty rows. Trim the pool with one of the four presets, or keep every dish. Move each plate up to its row with a tap, a drag or the one-at-a-time card. Type in any family specialties, give the board a title like Our Thanksgiving, ranked, and save the picture.

Can I add my family's own dishes?

Yes. Type a dish into the add field and it appears as a tile, or paste a list of several. You can also take a photo of grandma's casserole and add it as a picture; it is kept in this browser and never uploaded anywhere. Family additions sit right next to the drawn dishes.

Is stuffing the same as dressing?

Mostly, yes. Both are seasoned bread or cornbread mixed with broth, onion and celery. Traditionally stuffing is cooked inside the turkey and dressing is baked in a separate dish, but in practice the word a family uses often depends on region, with dressing more common in the South. This template uses stuffing for the tile.

Can the whole family rank Thanksgiving dinner together?

Yes. Drop the template link in the family chat and ask every relative to rank it and send back what they made. Up to twelve of those replies fit on the group page. You get the family consensus for each dish, a list of the plates that divide the table, and a view of which relatives eat alike.

Pictures: Emoji: Noto Emoji by Google (Apache-2.0). Other drawings: TierFolk. Full picture credits.