TierFolk

Pizza Toppings Tier List

Every pizza order is a small negotiation, so settle it once and for all. This board holds 39 toppings, drawn as little pictures, from pepperoni and mushrooms to hot honey, potato and a cracked egg. Rank them alone, or send the link around before the next group order.

See our ranking and why

  • Drawn and emoji topping tiles
  • 39 toppings, four presets
  • Merge friends' rankings
Fast on a phone. Tap an item, then a tier, or rank one by one with big buttons.
Your pictures stay here. They are resized and kept in your browser, never uploaded.
Clean exports. HD PNG in social sizes and a video reveal, with no watermark.
Rank with friends. Merge everyone's links into one group tier list.

Updated

How to rank the pizza toppings template

  1. Rank it yourselfStart from the full tray of 39, or choose Classic toppings, Meats, Veggies or Cheeses to keep the fight in one lane.
  2. Start from our rankingLoad our tiers, where pineapple sits in B and anchovies in D, and move whatever you think we got wrong.
  3. Show the verdictDownload a PNG for the group chat, or record the video reveal that drops toppings in one row at a time.

Our ranking

One opinion from the TierFolk editors, argued tier by tier below. Updated 2026-11-13. How we rank.

S
  • Pepperoni
  • Sausage
  • Mushrooms
  • Fresh mozzarella
  • Hot honey
A
  • Bacon
  • Basil
  • Garlic
  • Jalapeños
  • Onions
  • Prosciutto
  • Meatballs
  • Extra cheese
  • Ricotta
B
  • Green peppers
  • Black olives
  • Ham
  • Pineapple
  • Red onions
  • Spinach
  • Salami
  • Red pepper flakes
  • Pesto
  • Chicken
C
  • Tomatoes
  • Green olives
  • Banana peppers
  • Feta
  • Ground beef
  • Sun-dried tomatoes
  • Artichoke hearts
D
  • Anchovies
  • Broccoli
  • Corn

S tier. Toppings that make any pizza better and work on any crust. Pepperoni crisps and adds salt and gentle heat, sausage brings savory richness, and mushrooms add an earthy depth that pairs with almost everything. Fresh mozzarella turns a plain pie into something special, and hot honey, a newer favorite, adds sweet heat that lifts pepperoni and sausage even higher.

A tier. Excellent, but best as a second topping rather than the star. Bacon and prosciutto add salt and crunch, meatballs make a pie feel like dinner, and garlic, basil and onions bring flavor without weight. Jalapeños are the cleanest heat on the board. Extra cheese and ricotta are crowd-pleasers, though a pizza with too much cheese can turn heavy fast.

B tier. Good in the right company. Green peppers, black olives and red onions shine on a supreme pizza and fade on their own. Ham and pineapple need each other, which is the whole Hawaiian argument. Salami is a fine pepperoni alternative, chicken depends on the sauce, spinach on how dry the oven keeps it. Pesto and pepper flakes are great finishers but rarely the reason to order.

C tier. Toppings that have fans but need the right pizza. Fresh tomato slices can water down the pie. Green olives and banana peppers are sharp and divisive. Feta works on a Greek-style pizza and feels odd elsewhere. Ground beef is milder than sausage, and sun-dried tomatoes and artichoke hearts suit a white or gourmet pie better than a classic red one.

D tier. Each has its corner of the world where it is normal, and its fans have a point. For most people ordering a regular pie, though, these are the hardest sell. Anchovies bring a strong salty fish flavor that dominates a slice. Broccoli can turn soft and bitter in the oven, and sweet corn is a familiar topping in parts of Europe and Asia but unusual on most American menus.

All 39 items in this template
  • Pepperoni
  • Sausage
  • Bacon
  • Ham
  • Pineapple
  • Mushrooms
  • Onions
  • Red onions
  • Green peppers
  • Black olives
  • Green olives
  • Jalapeños
  • Banana peppers
  • Extra cheese
  • Fresh mozzarella
  • Ricotta
  • Feta
  • Spinach
  • Tomatoes
  • Sun-dried tomatoes
  • Basil
  • Garlic
  • Chicken
  • Ground beef
  • Meatballs
  • Salami
  • Prosciutto
  • Anchovies
  • Shrimp
  • Broccoli
  • Corn
  • Eggplant
  • Artichoke hearts
  • Arugula
  • Red pepper flakes
  • Hot honey
  • Egg
  • Potato
  • Pesto

Disagree? Press Start from our ranking above and move things, or Rank it yourself from an empty board.

The 39 toppings on the tray

Meats: pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, chicken, ground beef, meatballs, salami and prosciutto, plus anchovies and shrimp from the sea. Vegetables cover the delivery menu standards, like mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives and spinach, and the wood-fired crowd's favorites, such as arugula, artichoke hearts, eggplant and sun-dried tomatoes.

Cheese gets four tiles of its own: extra cheese, fresh mozzarella, ricotta and feta. Heat comes as jalapeños, banana peppers, red pepper flakes and hot honey. The wild cards are pineapple, corn, potato, egg and pesto, each of which is normal somewhere in the world and controversial somewhere else.

The pictures are a mix of Noto Emoji artwork and simple drawings we made ourselves, credited on this page. Prefer a photo of your own slice? Add it from your device; it stays in this browser.

Four presets, four kinds of argument

Classic toppings holds 17 of the names you see on almost any pizzeria board, from pepperoni to anchovies, and it is the quickest round for a big group. Meats has 11, the seafood included. Veggies has 19, which is a real test of whether someone likes vegetables or merely tolerates them. Cheeses is a short four-way that gets surprisingly heated.

A tip for big groups: rank the Classic preset first and save the full tray for the people who stayed. Anyone who has an opinion on arugula versus spinach will happily go another round.

How to rank a topping, not a pizza

Judge the topping on a plain cheese pie from a decent shop, not the best pizza you ever had. That keeps the comparison fair, since almost anything tastes good on a great crust. Then ask the single-topping question: would you order this one alone? Pepperoni passes easily; corn, for most people, does not.

Texture matters after baking. Pepperoni curls and crisps, mushrooms can turn watery, spinach wilts, and bacon either shatters or goes chewy depending on the oven. Arugula, and often fresh basil, go on after the bake, which is why they taste brighter. Also watch combinations: pineapple with ham or jalapeños is a different conversation from pineapple alone. Whatever wins here, someone will ask what to drink with it; the soda tier list settles that.

Pineapple and the other great divides

The Hawaiian pizza did not come from Hawaii. It is widely credited to Sam Panopoulos, a Greek-born restaurant owner in Chatham, Ontario, who put pineapple and ham on a pie in 1962. Half a century later, it is still the most reliable way to start an argument in any group chat.

Anchovies are the other line in the sand: a salty punch that pizza lovers in Italy take for granted and many delivery customers send back. The margherita has a gentler story. Legend says it was named for Queen Margherita of Italy during a visit to Naples in 1889, with tomato, mozzarella and basil standing for the colors of the flag; historians debate the details, but it makes a nice opener.

In the US, polls usually find pepperoni the favorite topping by a clear margin, which is why it sits at the top of our list and probably yours.

Ordering for a group: half-and-half by the numbers

Before ordering for a group, send the template link to everyone, collect their ranked links and paste them into the group tier list maker. The consensus board shows which toppings belong on the shared pies and which arguments to avoid. It also shows who ranks like whom, so pair those two on a half-and-half.

A simple rule keeps the order moving: every pie gets one topping from the group's S or A rows, and anything in someone's D row stays off the shared pies and goes on a personal half instead. On a movie-night Discord, rank while the delivery is on its way, then post the board when the boxes arrive.

Our ranking places 34 toppings, the ones most pizza menus offer. Shrimp, eggplant, arugula, egg and potato are left in the pool, because they are great on the right pizza and hard to judge on an everyday one.

Ranking pizza chains or styles instead

A pizza tier list often means chains or styles rather than toppings. For chains, the pizza preset on the fast food tier list lines up Domino's, Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, Little Caesars, Marco's Pizza and Pizza Pizza. For styles like New York, Chicago deep dish, Detroit, Neapolitan or Sicilian, paste them into the text tier list maker and rank them in a minute.

Dessert after the pizza? The ice cream flavors ranking is next door.

Questions

What are the top 3 pizza toppings?

In US polls, pepperoni usually comes first by a wide margin, and sausage and mushrooms often follow, with bacon and extra cheese close behind. Rankings vary by country and by survey, so treat any top three as a starting point. Our ranking puts pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms in S, joined by fresh mozzarella and hot honey.

Does pineapple belong on pizza?

It belongs on the pizzas of the people who order it, which is a lot of people. Sweet pineapple works best with something salty or spicy, like ham or jalapeños, which is why the Hawaiian pizza has lasted since the 1960s. We put pineapple in B: good with the right partners, not a standalone star. Your board can say otherwise.

How do I make a pizza toppings tier list?

Open this template, pick a preset if you want only meats, veggies, cheeses or the classics, and choose Rank it yourself. Tap a topping and then a tier, drag it, or tap One by one. Add a missing topping by typing its name or adding a picture, then export a PNG or record the video reveal for social.

What is the best pizza topping?

Pepperoni wins more popularity contests than any other, and it earns that: it crisps at the edges, adds salt and a little spice, and works on any crust. For a more interesting answer, ask about the second topping. Mushrooms, sausage, hot honey and fresh basil each have strong cases. Rank them and see where your friends land.

Can I make a pizza tier list with my friends?

Yes. Send the template link, ask each friend to rank it and reply with their link, then paste the replies into the group page. It works out a consensus tier for every topping by median, lists the most argued ones, and shows who agrees with whom. The links are read in your browser, and the names you enter stay on your device.

Can I add a topping that is missing?

Type it into the item box, paste several at once, or add your own picture, and it joins the tray. Good additions include white sauce, barbecue chicken, capers, caramelized onions or a regional favorite. Additions live in your copy and autosave to My lists. Lists with your own pictures travel as a backup file rather than a link.

Pictures: Emoji: Noto Emoji by Google (Apache-2.0). Other drawings: TierFolk. Full picture credits.